Which Is Better: Capital Growth Or Rental Yield?
Most Popular Related Articles
Whilst it is possible to have both strong capital growth and a high rental yield, it is rare. More often than not it is a choice between one and the other.
The answer to this question is not as straight forward or obvious as one would hope because different personal and financial circumstances and investment strategies give rise to different responses.
On the one hand going for strong capital growth seems an obvious choice because of the potential to generate long-term capital profit. However, rental yields on high growth properties tend to be low meaning these properties are almost always negatively geared (that is, expenses (like mortgage interest and other costs) exceed the rent earned).
Whilst this provides the investor with some useful tax breaks (under current tax legislation) it still means they will be out of pocket each month until the property is sold.
Properties with a higher rental yield on the other hand, usually provide for a positively geared investment property (that is, where the rent exceeds all costs) meaning the investment pays for itself. It also means the property is generating cash reserves which can be used to pay down the loan or for any other purpose.
The downside is that when it comes time to sell, the capital gain is likely to be substantially less than that of the strong capital growth property, especially when taking into account the compounding impact of year-on-year growth.
Importantly, whilst it is possible to have both strong capital growth and a high rental yield, it is rare.
More often than not it is a choice between one and the other. And this in turn comes down to what best fits the investor’s objectives, risk profile and is the most affordable.
Strong capital growth strategy
I would define strong capital growth as inflation plus 4 per cent to 5 per cent annually over the long term. So you are probably looking at growth rates at between 6.5 per cent and 7.5 per cent.
The risk with this strategy is, as alluded to above, that you’ll likely be out of pocket while you hold the investment and will be subject to interest rate risk, whereby increases in mortgage rates can be painful, especially if there are contractual and market constraints which limit the ability to raise rents.
There are ways to mitigate these risks, like borrowing less and taking out a fixed rate loan, but generally speaking this is an ongoing problem for this type of strategy. In addition, a strong capital growth strategy places all your eggs in the one basket whereby all the profit is made sometime in future when the property is sold.
In the meantime, investors typically run at a loss and with negative cash flow.